Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches

Rate this book
Goodreads Choice Award
Nominee for Best Fantasy (2022)
A warm and uplifting novel about an isolated witch whose opportunity to embrace a quirky new family--and a new love--changes the course of her life.

As one of the few witches in Britain, Mika Moon knows she has to hide her magic, keep her head down, and stay away from other witches so their powers don't mingle and draw attention. And as an orphan who lost her parents at a young age and was raised by strangers, she's used to being alone and she follows the rules...with one exception: an online account, where she posts videos pretending to be a witch. She thinks no one will take it seriously.

But someone does. An unexpected message arrives, begging her to travel to the remote and mysterious Nowhere House to teach three young witches how to control their magic. It breaks all of the rules, but Mika goes anyway, and is immediately tangled up in the lives and secrets of not only her three charges, but also an absent archaeologist, a retired actor, two long-suffering caretakers, and...Jamie. The handsome and prickly librarian of Nowhere House would do anything to protect the children, and as far as he's concerned, a stranger like Mika is a threat. An irritatingly appealing threat.

As Mika begins to find her place at Nowhere House, the thought of belonging somewhere begins to feel like a real possibility. But magic isn't the only danger in the world, and when a threat comes knocking at their door, Mika will need to decide whether to risk everything to protect a found family she didn't know she was looking for....

318 pages, Paperback

First published August 23, 2022

Loading interface...
Loading interface...

About the author

Sangu Mandanna

19 books3,442 followers
Sangu Mandanna was four years old when an elephant chased her down a forest road and she decided to write her first story about it. Seventeen years and many, many manuscripts later, she signed her first book deal. Sangu now lives in Norwich, a city in the east of England, with her husband and kids.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
57,639 (35%)
4 stars
70,652 (43%)
3 stars
27,703 (17%)
2 stars
4,162 (2%)
1 star
800 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 26,525 reviews
Profile Image for Riley.
447 reviews23.1k followers
September 7, 2022
THIS WAS SO GOOD!!!

- Practical Magic x The House in the Cerulean Sea
- grumpy/sunshine romance between a witch and a handsome librarian
- found family vibes
- lots of mixing potions and casting spells

11/10 would recommend, perfect for a cozy fall read!
Profile Image for Hannah Azerang.
138 reviews107k followers
August 7, 2023
one of the most wholesome, heartwarming stories i’ve ever read 💙
Profile Image for Destiny Sidwell.
77 reviews93.8k followers
October 26, 2023
3.5 ⭐️
ugh! this was just so cute and cozy !!

i don’t usually love kids in books but this was just adorable! the setting , the magic, and the characters were just great! such an enjoyable read
Profile Image for Nilufer Ozmekik.
2,527 reviews51.4k followers
September 18, 2023
I fell in love with this book and that extremely unconventional, batsh*t crazy, entertaining family!

A lonely, gold hearted girl, creator of magical positions, 31 years old Mika Moon is a member of Secret Society of Witches. She’s an orphan raised by Primrose Beatrice Everly: the leader of their very discreet foundation. Quick correction: she was raised by nannies and tutors whose memories have been erased as soon as they’ve found out her secret abilities. Primrose had strict rules and she barely talked about Mika’s family of witches who lost their lives.

Mika get used to be lonely, not spending time at a place more than a month, not making intimate connections and lasting bounds. But one of her videos she’s made for YouTube for having fun attracted someone’s attention who knows lot about witches. The man’s name is Ian Kubo-Hawthorn, an eccentric retired actor in his 80’s : a member of Nowhere house gang. And he’s ready to make an offer to Mika that she doesn’t want to refuse.

He sends her a message as witch wanted and that picks interest of Mika who drives her Broomstick ( not literally, she named her car like that) and she meets with Motley Crue, inhabitants of Nowhere House.
Let’s introduce all of them one by one:
Ken, bald, Japanese, a man who is kind and nice at the same time, in his 70’s, creating magic in garden.
I already mentioned ball of fire, sarcastic, energetic, vivid Ian, who is Ken’s husband, living in a cottage next to Nowhere house.
Lucie, motherly, kind, caring, housekeeper in her late fifties.
Jamie, Irish charm, in mid-thirties, graduated from Cambridge, brooding, introvert librarian who is not happy about Mika’s arrival.

And three little magical orphan girls: Rosette ( oldest of them, 10, black, social, friendly) , Terracotta( 8, rebellious, Vietnamese), Altamira ( 7, Palestinian)

The owner of the Nowhere House is archeologist Lilian Nowhere who is busy, buried her head in her secret projects, adopted those girls but she doesn’t have time to take care of them or teach them how they control their powers. Yes, Lillian is a witch just like the girls!

And here comes Ian’s offer: he wants to hire Mika as a tutor to prevent an upcoming disaster. A few months later Edward Foxhaven will stop by at the house to extract important paperwork from Lillian’s office and during that meeting they don’t want Edward catch any suspicious activity from little girls ( like putting house on fire or flying around the garden) If he realizes they are not normal little orphan girls, he can call the authorities. And Lillian cannot meet him at house because she has more important things to do!

Mika finds this situation very dangerous because she’s thought that witches should stay separated because their accumulated powers can be dangerous and if Primrose finds out this situation she does anything in power to separate those girls.

But she already empathizes with them and the Nowhere House members including hostile Jamie can be her family she’s never had in her life. So she accepts to give it a try.
And the fun actually begins. Do you want to know what will happen? Just grab a copy and enjoy your full ride!

Overall: very eccentric, huggable, vivid characters, heartwarming chapters, romance, magic, secrets, entertaining schemes: I’m sold! This is so amazing! I hope I can read more secret society books in near future!

Special thanks to NetGalley and Berkley Publishing for sharing this amazing digital reviewer copy with me in exchange my honest opinions.

blog
instagram
facebook
twitter
Profile Image for urwa.
331 reviews212 followers
October 3, 2022
2.5 stars
Oh, dear. This was the most twee book I've ever read. I was hoping this would be a fun cozy romance with some fantasy like the blurb suggested but it was more like eating a cake and finding out it's mostly whipping cream and no cake. The book tries its best to come off as warm and wholesome with the whole cottagecore vibe, which I respect and enjoyed but there isn't much substance to it. The plot is straightforward and predictable which could be excusable if the characters had any depth. I didn't really care for any of them. The three children about whom everyone is supposed to be head over heels for are forgettable and not at all distinguishable except that one of them is slightly more murderous. The entire thing feels shallow and a cheaper version of The House in the Cerulean Sea. I also wasn't a big fan of the romance, it felt pretty meh; the sex scene was totally random and read like something out of Wattpad. The casual swearing and throwing around of the word "penises" and "fuck" also kinda felt unnecessary? Like I don't mind swearing in books, but I felt as if the swearing was out of place and broke the immersion for me here.
I really was excited to read this book, and I'm disappointed my first read for spooky season turned out to be a dud.
Profile Image for Heather Mclarry.
247 reviews28.7k followers
August 28, 2023
4.5⭐️ stop what you’re doing and read this WARM COZY WITCHY MASTERPIECE. We know how much a I love Beach read by Emily Henry. For some reason I feel like this is like the witchy version of that book!!!!! The main focus wasn’t the romance but it was still very prevalent. JAMIE WITH THE WORDS OMFG “your heart’s the strongest fucking thing I’ve ever known” *SWOONING*

This was the perfect mix of magic, found family and romance 🎃🍂🪄😭
Profile Image for emma.
2,083 reviews66k followers
December 22, 2022
would you look at that. turns out i have a heart after all.

this is a magic book, in that it is about magic, but also in that it granted me a wish: this is what i wanted the house on the cerulean sea to be. mixed with eva ibbotson.

in other words, a dream.

the first quarter is extremely cute and perfect, and then we go off the rails a little bit - please less sex and romance and swearing and more witch children who want to commit murder - and the end is like the cutesy happy ending version of happily ever after, but overall...this is sweet and fun!

i would say no complaints, but i'm a hateful gremlin! and i liked the world of this.

bottom line: a book so good it made me speak in marketing copy!

3.5

------------------------
currently-reading updates

this title...need i say more

(thanks to the publisher for the e-arc)

------------

reading books by asian authors for aapi month!

book 1: kim jiyoung, born 1982
book 2: siren queen
book 3: the heart principle
book 4: n.p.
book 5: the hole
book 6: set on you
book 7: disorientation
book 8: parade
book 9: if i had your face
book 10: joan is okay
book 11: strange weather in tokyo
book 12: sarong party girls
book 13: the wind-up bird chronicle
book 14: portrait of a thief
book 15: sophie go's lonely hearts club
book 16: chemistry
book 17: heaven
book 18: the atlas six
book 19: the remains of the day
book 20: is everyone hanging out without me? and other concerns
book 21: why not me?
book 22: when the tiger came down the mountain
book 23: the lies we tell
book 24: to paradise
book 25: pachinko
book 26: you are eating an orange. you are naked.
book 27: cursed bunny
book 28: almond
book 29: a tiny upward shove
book 30: ms ice sandwich
book 31: the woman in the library
book 32: nothing like i imagined
book 33: night sky with exit wounds
book 34: all the lovers in the night
book 35: the white book
book 36: the woman in the purple skirt
book 37: the very secret society of irregular witches
Profile Image for Brady Lockerby.
85 reviews50.9k followers
October 16, 2023
SO cute!!! Imagine House in the Cerulean Sea, but make it a bit witchy. Found family, grumpy/sunshine, misfits that become the perfect fit. Loved loved loved. Highly recommend listening to it, the audiobook was perfection!
Profile Image for chan ☆.
1,132 reviews54.8k followers
March 29, 2024
i liked basically nothing about this, i'm so sorry.

i'm reading it for a video, otherwise it would have been an instant DNF. i'm not into cozy/"charming" books like this. and i really despised the love interest. he was a dick and a reveal near the end of the book was deeply strange and unsettling to me.

also don't really feel like this is a romance and as i'm reading it for a romance video i'm more irritated than i would be otherwise lol.
Profile Image for Emily (Books with Emily Fox on Youtube).
578 reviews64.7k followers
November 1, 2022
I'm a big fan of the "found family" trope and it was well executed in this book.

However, everyone here desperately needs therapy and I never forgave Jaime for what he told the MC (
Profile Image for Emily May.
2,057 reviews311k followers
Shelved as 'dnf'
August 30, 2022
DNF - 45%

Sorry. Bit too cute and twee for me. I saw someone compare it to the whimsical The House in the Cerulean Sea, which I also could not finish, and that seems about right. I'm still on the search for one of those old school adult urban fantasy stories with drama, mythology and sexual chemistry. They must still exist somewhere, right?
Profile Image for Snjez.
841 reviews718 followers
August 20, 2023
2.5 stars

Mixed feelings about this book. I have to say that I enjoyed it when I started it and it was going well for a while. I liked the diverse cast of characters and it was fun watching Mika work with the girls.

As the story progressed it started to fizzle out for me. It was a bit repetitive at times and predictable, and there wasn't much character development. The overall premise reminded me too much of The House in the Cerulean Sea. I love that one, but this one pales in comparison.

The romance part didn't work for me at all. It felt forced and I didn't feel any chemistry between Mika and Jamie. The s*x scene came out of nowhere. It felt cringey and I don't think it fit with this type of story.

This was my first read by this author and I'm not sold on the writing style, to be honest. It feels kind of simplistic and childish at times.

Edit: rating rounded down
Profile Image for toointofiction.
254 reviews317 followers
April 5, 2023
"This is either going to be the miracle you hoped for or it's going to be an absolute fucking disaster."

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Spice Meter: 🌶️

This is a spoiler-free ARC review from Netgalley

📍Release Date: August 23, 2022📍

I am seriously losing my mind over the cuteness of this book. It was the most wholesome read so far. I felt pure joy, I laughed, I met some very unusual, delightful characters, aaaaand I cried a little too. All in all, this was a reading goal success. There wasn't much in the way of conflict for more than half of the book, (so don't expect an intensely engaging story) not counting grumpy and sunshine getting to know each other (you know how that is 🤗🤗), which left a lot of room for really funny, happy moments and bonding that may or may not have cured my depression a little. The use of the found family trope was excellent. It was a very pure story. Also, the writing style reminded me of Good Omens by Neil Gaiman and Terry Pratchett a little bit, with its tasteful humour, quirky characters, and delightfully ridiculous situations. I don't know if this is intended to be as a standalone, but I demand another book. I don't care. I want it.

Mika Moon, the main character, was delightful and really entertaining to read about. She was such a lovable character and such an awesome, badass witch. I really loved her, I laughed with her and found myself empathising with her, which means the character was written well. I also loved her attitude towards life, in spite of the loneliness she experienced all her life, even though I could never match it. I'm more the grumpy rather than the sunshine 😅😅 Mika also has a dog, her name is Circe and she's absolutely adorable (duuuuuh), and some koi fish named Hecate, Freyja, Medusa, and Ceridwen, all names which I really love and want to use for my pets. So you can imagine how much identified with this particular witch. I should mention that she also named her car Broomstick which is what I want to name my car now if I'm ever not broke long enough to buy one that is...😅😅

As expected, the love interest was amazing as well. James Kelly was delightful, hilariously grumpy, kind, and really really hot. This particular reader approves 🤩🤩 You should see how adorable he looked trying to convince himself he wasn't helplessly crushing on the charming, beautiful witch. He had his own found-family story and it was so emotional, and beautiful. If I could take Mika and Jamie, wrap them in a blanket, and give them milk and cookies I would. He was willing to do anything to protect the ones he loved. Especially the three young witches he was taking care of. He was also a reminder that men like this only exist in books written by women...I did not appreciate the reminder, to be perfectly honest 😑😑

I found the romance excruciatingly slow, which for me is pretty much ideal because I'm an uncurable masochist. I want to be tortured with lingering looks, longing, 'innocent' hand holding, and sweet, 'friendly' words until eventually, after more than half a book later they finally give me what I want, (which is more or less what happens here). In fact, the longer they take to get together the better. Yes, I have a problem. I will NOT do anything about it except read more exruciatingly slow-burn romances. Call me crazy, I don't care. I also definitely have a weak spot for the grumpy x sunshine trope. I can't help it. It's delightful every time. Just the idea of an insanely energetic, extroverted person teaming up with a broody, antisocial introvert brings me an innumerable amount of joy.

As for all the other characters, there isn't a single one I don't love unconditionally. Well...there is one actually, but he can suck it. He doesn't matter. Each character had their own unique, quirky personality, they were so damn lovable, funny, and cute. I had such a blast with all of them. Primrose may have had a stick up her ass but I still really really liked her. Ian, Ken, and Lucie (the girls' caregivers) were incredible. As for said girls, Rosetta, Altimira, and Terracotta, you couldn't find cuter witches no matter how hard you tried. They were so adorable and just as funny as everyone else in this book. It was such a brilliant experience with all of them.


I highly recommend it.
Profile Image for chloé ✿.
132 reviews2,769 followers
October 9, 2023
3 stars for this wholesome, magical novel🌙🍵

one word: twee.

please bear with me for this very poorly constructed review. i’m tired.

this was whimsical, witchy, and lighthearted. in my opinion, that’s the perfect start to October. read if you’re a fan of found family, contemporary magic, a grumpy/sunshine romance AND you don’t mind twee.

this is the love child of The House in the Cerulean Sea & Practical Magic 💫

i have sarah j maas to blame for expecting deep world building of every fantasy story i read, but i realize not every book can/should be a series. still, i would have liked slightly more details in certain areas and a little more character development.

overall, this is super cute and a quick read that is perfect for Autumn. definitely pick this up if the synopsis sounds interesting to you and you like twee books.

happy spooky, witchy season! 🤗
Profile Image for PamG.
992 reviews668 followers
August 20, 2022
Sangu Mandanna brings warmth, diversity, and humor to a magical realism novel with romance, danger, and suspense. The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches is one of my favorite books of 2022. Witch Mika Moon has been taught that she needs to hide her magic and stay away from other witches to avoid drawing attention to their magic. As an orphan raised by a stranger, she’s used to being alone and following most of the rules. However, she is a bit of a rebel. She posts videos online pretending to be a witch and assuming no one will believe it.

However, someone does. They message her, asking her to come to Nowhere House to teach three young witches how to control their magic. Breaking the rules she’s grown up with, Mika accepts and gets involved with the odd assortment at the house. There’s the absent archaeologist, the retired actor, the librarian, the housekeeper, the gardener, and three witches ranging in age from seven to ten. Mika learns that there are secrets, and soon, danger and suspense come into play.

Mika has a great personality. She is likeable and relatable. Her loneliness and lack of connection to others is palpable. I loved her sense of humor. The other main characters have great depth as well. The author does a great job of showing readers each character’s feelings as well as their unspoken thoughts. Terracotta, the middle child, was fantastic, but all three children had distinctive personalities. It was fascinating to watch them discover new aspects of themselves. These unique characters made the book much more enthralling to read.

This is a wonderfully executed story with extraordinary and diverse characters and a setting that came alive. The writing and dialogue flow well. The chemistry between Mika and Jamie creates an added layer to the storyline. There are unpredictable moments in the story that provide some unexpected twists at the end of the novel. I did not want this book to end. My only quibble is that I wanted more suspense in the novel. Themes include loneliness, lack of belonging, friendship, connections, love, community, trust, and family.

Overall, this is a warm, uplifting and feel-good novel that brought me a lot of reading joy. It captivated me from beginning to end. If you like charming and heartwarming stories with humor, romance, secrets, and some danger, then this is definitely a book to check out. I’m looking forward to reading more by this author.

Berkley Publishing Group and Sangu Mandanna provided a complimentary digital ARC of this novel via NetGalley. This is my honest review. Opinions are mine alone and are not biased in any way. Publication date is currently set for August 23, 2022. This review was originally posted at Mystery and Suspense Magazine.

-------------------------------------
My 4.72 star review rounded up to 5 stars will be coming soon.
Profile Image for Will Byrnes.
1,327 reviews121k followers
September 22, 2022
…witches were always orphans. According to Primrose, this was because of a spell that went wrong in some bygone era. Mika was certain this tale was a figment of Primrose’s imagination, but she also had no better explanation because the fact remained: when a witch was born, she would find herself orphaned shortly thereafter. It didn’t matter where in the world the witch was born, and the cause of death could be anything from innocuous illnesses to everyday accidents, but it was inevitable.
-------------------------------------
WITCH WANTED. Live-in tutor wanted for three young witches. Must have nerves of steel. Previous teaching experience not necessary. Witchiness essential.
We have all answered want ads, but I expect there are few (you know who you are) who have come across one like that. But Mika Moon has been looking for an opportunity. There are not many witches in England and they have lived very separate lives in Mandanna’s witchy world. Apparently when they get together, their magic, which manifests as something like those specks you see in the air when bright light shines in an enclosed space, but gold, visible only to those with witch blood, combine and draw attention. (maybe they are scraped from yellow bricks? ) Also, as noted at top, they are all orphans. There are quarterly meetings of England’s witch population, well, a portion of them anyway, but they are living very separate lives. (People come and go so quickly here.) Their cover story, of course, is that they are a book club.

Mika was unusual in the group, being the child of a witch, and the granddaughter of a witch. It appears that most witches in this world were born to parents the Potter-verse might refer to as Muggles. When she was orphaned in India, Primrose Beatrice Everly, maybe the oldest living witch, found her and brought her to England, where she was raised in Primrose’s home. Not the worst life, but a lonely one.
Sometimes, when she looked back on her childhood, Mika had trouble remembering all her nannies and tutors. There had been so very many of them that she would sometimes catch herself forgetting names or struggling to conjure up a face or attaching a memory to the wrong person.

What she did remember, in perfect, crystalline detail, was the loneliness. She remembered how much she’d longed for company. A parent, a sister, a friend. Someone who was there because they wanted to be and not because they were paid handsomely to be.
Mika amuses herself by posting videos on line of her pretending to be a witch, expecting that no one would believe she really is one. But someone does see, thus the Help Wanted ad finding its way to her. And the game is afoot, or maybe a-broom.

description
Sangu Mandanna - image from her site

In a way, Mika’s experience is a bit like Dorothy’s when she first set foot in Oz. Where Am I? What is this place? Although she doesn’t, she could easily, on her arrival, have said, “Circe, [that being her dog] I don’t think we’re in Brighton any more.” There are three young witch girls living there. How is that even possible? Their combined magic is manifest, and a sure sign of imminent peril!
“Too much magic in one place attracts attention,” [Primrose] would say. “Even wards can only hide so much. And attracting attention, as witches have discovered time and time again over the centuries, is dangerous. Alone is how we survive.”
She meets with the four grownups of Nowhere House (yes, really) first. They are very welcoming, well, except for one, who is as crusty as he is handsome. The lady of the house, (Lillian Nowhere, and thus the name of the house. Yes, really.) absent at present, had adopted the girls from different parts of the world. While it is clear that this is a loving household, it is also clear that someone needs to train the girls in how to manage their unusual gift. In the role of Wicked Witch, there is an accountant, engaged by the absent Lillian, set to arrive in six weeks, and he holds enormous power over them, the girls in particular. If their magic is not locked down it could result in the dissolution of the household. So, no pressure.

One thing Mika brings with her is a true heart and an eagerness to help, and a cheerfulness that runs into some barriers. There is no wondering for us if Mika a good witch or a bad witch as she teaches the girls not only how to better manage their power, gaining some trust and affection. But not all members of the household are convinced. One of the girls is overtly unhappy that Mika is there and does her best to be unpleasant to her, and unengaged.
As for Mika in particular, honestly, I think she represented a ray of sunshine and hope that I needed when I started writing this novel in lockdown. - from the United by Pop interview
Then there is Jamie, the crusty, protective librarian who had the most responsibility for the girls. If you have ever seen a Hallmark movie, you can see what’s coming the instant these two cross paths. I am not saying that I mind this. I have been dragged to the living room to watch (more than) my share of Hallmark movies (Could you loosen those ropes a bit, dear? ) so I speak from a reasonable amount of experience. I will confess that I actually like some of these things, however formulaic. And the romance here is indeed formulaic, albeit charmingly done and with some nice magical elements.
I’ve loved stories with fantasy and magic since I was a little girl, and I was an eager tween when I first discovered my love of romance novels. I think it was inevitable that I would write a book that combined fantasy with romance, but as I’ve grown older, I’ve also discovered a love of stories about found families, outcasts finding a place to belong, and the magic of the everyday. I wanted to write a book with all of these things. - from the United by Pop interview
Thankfully, there are other things going on. In her interview with Verve, Mandanna recalls being in love with the play, Les Miserables as a teen, and acting out all the parts herself, believing that there would never be a chance for someone with brown skin to play any of those roles. Even her favorite characters from classic literature seemed out of reach, and rom-coms and other forms all seemed to feature females of only one sort. So, when she started writing it was with an eye toward including people who looked like her. Thus, Mika was born in India. And the girls are diverse. One is black, one is from Vietnam and another is Palestinian. (I am sure that it is purely a coincidence that there are three children in the novel and Mandanna has three of her own. )

Mika struggles with her need for a family, for acceptance of what she is, for love. She has been raised to believe that attachment is lethal, as once non-witch people in her life learn of her powers, only trouble follows. So, don’t get attached, don’t settle in, keep moving, and stay away from other witches. It makes for a very lonely life. But with that mindset, how can you accept what appears to be a real connection to a loving family if they could yank it away at any time? This applies both to the family and her relationship with Jamie. But she feels herself falling in love with this family. Isolation sucks.

Mandanna wrote this during the COVID lockdowns, so Mika has taken on the additional task of standing in for so many of us who struggled with disconnection, who were unable to have physical contact with family and other people for a long time.

Gripes are modest. Yes, it is a romance, but I found it a bit jarring for a book that was going along reading very much like a YA title to then get a fair bit steamy a time or two. Not surprising that someone who has made her mark writing for a younger audience (The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches is her first novel for adults) might retain a lot of that sensibility while adding more adult elements. (There is the odd profanity as well) But it felt unnecessary. What we gain from those scenes could have been accomplished with much less detail. I wanted to know so much more about Primrose, and how she located her special orphans. Ditto for Lillian. And maybe how witches who are constantly moving from place to place manage to make a living. While the setup makes sense to establish Mika’s situation and that of the residents of that special place, it does not seem likely to stand up well to much expansion.

I really liked the notion of making magic not only visually manifest, but with its own personality. There is some LOL material here as well. It is not a long book. The story rolls along quickly. It is engaging, as Mika is an appealing lead and her situation is tailor-made to pluck your heartstrings. It is a fast, enjoyable read, perfect for when you might be looking for something to cheer you up. You will be charmed. While reading The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches I expect there will be Nowhere you would rather be.
She hadn’t understood how exhausting and heartbreaking it had been to hide such a big part of herself all these years, to reshape and contort herself into something more acceptable. She hadn’t realised just how heavy her mask had been until she’d discovered what it was to live without it.

Review posted – September 16, 2022

Publication date – August 23, 2022


I received an ARE of The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches from Berkley in return for a fair review, and a few obscure ingredients for a potion. Thanks, folks, and thanks to NetGalley for facilitating.




This review has been cross-posted on my site, Coot’s Reviews. Stop by and say Hi!

=============================EXTRA STUFF

Links to the author’s personal, Instagram, and Twitter pages

Profile - from her site
Sangu Mandanna was four years old when an elephant chased her down a forest road and she decided to write her first story about it. Seventeen years and many, many manuscripts later, she signed her first book deal. Sangu now lives in Norwich, a city in the east of England, with her husband and kids.
Interviews
-----She Reads - August Guest Editor Sangu Mandanna on The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches
-----Verve - A GIRL LIKE ME: SANGU MANDANNA - from 2019 – so not specific for this book, but interesting intel about the author
-----The Fantasy Hive - INTERVIEW WITH SANGU MANDANNA (THE VERY SECRET SOCIETY OF IRREGULAR WITCHES) by Niles Shukla
-----United by Pop - Sangu Mandanna On Her Bewitching New Rom-Com, The Very Secret Society Of Irregular Witches by Kate Oldfield
-----Writers Digest - Sangu Mandanna: On Writing Her First Novel for Adults by Robert Lee Brewer
Profile Image for Dorie  - Cats&Books :) .
1,071 reviews3,361 followers
September 22, 2023
This is a great little book about friendship, love, coming of age and finding the people who will love you for who you really are!!

Mika Moon has led a lonely life. Orphaned as a baby, she was taken in by Primrose Everly, who is, of course, a witch!! Although Mika never really experienced Primrose as a mother figure because she was raised by a series of nannies. As soon as a nanny suspected anything “magical” about Mika, she was quickly replaced.

In this present meeting of witches, Mika is being reprimanded for creating her witchy social media posts. Mika assures her that no one will actually believe she is a witch, as there are others out there posing as witches and the videos are just for fun! Only simple magic tricks are shared.

However not much later Mika receives an email advertising “WITCH WANTED as a tutor for 3 young witches”. Since Mika presently has no job she decides to go to the destination, Nowhere House, and see what this is all about. When she is introduced to the 3 young girls she immediately “could see the unmistakable gold dust motes of magic around them”.

In a nutshell, she accepts the job and we join her as she slowly wins over the others who live at Nowhere House including all 3 little girl witches. Her job is to teach the girls how to contain and use their magic and also how to “reign it in” when they don’t want to be discovered as witches.

The plot of the story is charming, the magic is fun to read about and there is enough here for entertainment and some background on witches in Britain.

I was all ready to recommend this as a YA novel, but there is a sex scene and occasional use of expletives!! Nothing that would bother most adults but just wanted to note this in case it is a trigger for some.

I can recommend this as a fun read with characters that are engaging, colorful and distinct.

I received an ARC of this novel from the publisher, Berkley, through NetGalley. It was my pleasure to read and review this novel.
Profile Image for Josu Diamond.
Author 9 books33.4k followers
January 14, 2024
POR FAVOR 😭😭

Empecé este libro porque me parecía diferente, gracioso y porque estoy descubriendo el cozy fantasy, pero no esperaba que terminara haciéndome llorar y todooo.

En La Sociedad Secreta de Brujas Rebeldes nos encontramos una historia que tiene muchos elementos, desde la magia y las brujas hasta la familia encontrada, un poco de romance y varios giros en la trama que me dejaron boquiabierto. Pero sí, todo se siente como un gran abrazo calentito por parte de Sangu Mandanna, que hace que no quieras ni despegarte del libro ni terminarlo. Quería quedarme a vivir con las tres niñas Ian, Jamie...

Una de las cosas que más voy a destacar de este libro es Mika, la protagonista. De verdad que pocas veces he leído un personaje así, con esa forma de enfrentarse a las situaciones complicadas, con esa bondad, pero también con ese poquito de humor negro...<7u> O sea, la manera en la que cuando hay algún contratiempo procesa las emociones... No sé, la única manera de saber a qué me refiero creo que es leyendo el libro. Me sorprendía muchísimo: no tiene la manera de actuar base de cualquier personaje de libro.

la brujita

En cuanto al romance, aunque hay un poquito de este elemento, la verdad es que no es lo primordial y no es hasta pasada la mitad de la novela donde empieza a ser algo más importante. Eso sí, es precioso, cargado de emoción y que hace que tu corazoncito se emocione mucho. También me ha encantado todo el tema de las brujas, las historias de las brujas antiguas, del resto de sociedades, los secretos... Creo que Mandanna tiene un don para contar historias; es de estas autoras que parece que te están contando la historia de manera oral, y de alguna forma, cala muy hondo.

Los giros en la trama me dejaron de piedra. Más que nada porque no consideraba que este libro fuera a ir in crescendo, pero así ha sido, ganando capas, emociones y sobre todo, convirtiendo lo que nacía como una historia sencilla y básica en algo mucho más grande y emocional. Pero sí, vaya, que me vinieron de repente varias cosas que no me veía venir y que consiguieron que la historia pasara de una novela divertida de tres o cuatro estrellas a una obra redonda.

Sin duda, volveré a leer a la autora si lanza algo similar. He salido ENCANTADO de esta lectura y ya echo de menos a todos los personajes.
Profile Image for Debra.
2,664 reviews35.7k followers
July 1, 2022
Pure Magic!

So good! While reading and when I finished this book, I sighed a big sigh of happiness. This book was just a pleasure through and through!!

Mika Moon was raised by strangers after her parents’ death when she was little. She spent most of her time alone and never felt part of a family. Now an adult, she is a witch who makes her own videos pretending to be a witch - are you still with me? Ian Kubo-Hawthorn has seen one of her videos and unlike others who think they are watching someone pretend to be a witch, he knows what he is seeing- a true witch! He sends her a message asking her to come to Nowhere House to teach three young witches how to control their magic.

This is a big no-no, but Mika decides to go, and this is where the magic truly happens. Not only does she meet the three young witches, but she meets the others at Nowhere house at all. Sometimes, life puts you where you truly need to be. I love the message of family and what makes a family. It was heartwarming and charming. There is also some romance, some humor and three unique young witches.

This book cast a spell on me!

Charming, full of heart, and magical!

#TheVerySecretSocietyofIrregularWitches #NetGalley

Thank you to Berkley Publishing Group and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.

Read more of my reviews at www.openbookposts.com


Profile Image for Rosh.
1,804 reviews2,718 followers
August 22, 2022
In a Nutshell: This is the sweetest and the cutest and the loveliest book I’ve read in ages. Imagine sunbeams and moonlight strewn together in a magical combo! Go for it without a doubt.

Story Synopsis:
Thirty-one year old Mika Moon has lived a life of solitude. As a witch, she knows that she cannot let the dangerous world know about her magical abilities. With no family or friends, lonely Mika resorts to posting “fake” witchy videos to an online account, just so that she can talk about her favourite topic – magic. She is sure no one will notice. She is wrong.
When she receives an anonymous message summoning her to a remote place called “Nowhere House” to teach magic to three young witches, she feels uncertain but goes there anyway. What follows is a cute, funny and sometimes dangerous adventure with Mika, her three young wards and their three not-so-young caretakers. Oh, and there’s Jamie too, who hates strangers. How will Mika adjust from being a loner to this sudden flurry of people in her life? Will she finally be able to settle in a place and call it home?



Where the book worked for me:
😍 The characters. Each and every character, including the surly ones. Their detailing is so precise that you can’t help understand their actions. Mika, her three little wards, the three caretakers, Jamie, and Circe the dog – all will cast a spell on you. The best are Mika and Jamie. With each of them using a different modus operandi to deal with the blows life has dealt them, their personalities are a study in contrasts. It’s very easy to love Mika, but try having a grumpy, anti-social hero who loves to spend more time with books and kids than with adults! Team Jamie FTW.

😍 I loved all the “magicky” things in the book. It was a wonderful experience to see an almost personified version of magic throughout the story. It never went over the top. Ditto for the representation of witches.

😍 The characters come from a variety of racial backgrounds – Indian, Irish, British (white and Black), Palestinian, Vietnamese – but none of the ethnicities are thrown at your face. This might have been just to ensure multiracial representation, but the characters are written as regular characters with no needless stress on their diversity. For instance, there’s no shoehorned “chai tea” or yoga making an appearance simply to justify Mika’s Indian roots. I loved seeing this normal portrayal of multicultural characters – it’s exactly how representation should be in this global world. (There’s LGBTQ+ rep also in the form of a gay married couple, and I bet you won’t find a cuter couple in contemporary fiction!)

😍 This novel nails the ‘found family’ trope. With such loveable yet quirky characters, the journey was anyway going to be exciting, but the way the author brought out the feeling of oneness amid these disparate individuals was just beautiful. None of the characters feel unidimensional.

😍 The Mika-Jamie link is quite guessable. (Not complaining – the book is a Fantasy-Romance after all.) But what I loved was how naturally it developed. There’s no insta-lust but a friendship turning into attraction turning into something greater. Romances are always so much better when written in slow-burn style. Also, I hate it when there’s steam for the sake of it. This one has those scenes when they make sense in the narrative flow.

😍 The writing is very quick and easy-going.


Where the book could have worked better for me:
😢 Why did the story have to get over so soon? There's no cliffhanger but I demand a sequel ASAP! I want to know what happens about a certain something that has been in existence since hundreds of years. Will Mika be able to modify/overthrow it?


Do you see the skew of my feedback? No surprise then that this book will get the highest rating I ever give to contemporary adult fiction. Recommended to anyone looking for a light and cosy and quick and soul-satisfying read. This was fantastic in every sense of the word. I am going to keep an eye out for all future Sangu Mandanna releases.

Note: It does have a lot of cuss words. If you don’t like seeing the F word thrown around casually and regularly, this won’t work for you.

4.75 stars.

My thanks to Hodder & Stoughton and NetGalley for the DRC of “The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches”. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.




———————————————
Connect with me through:
My Blog | The StoryGraph | Facebook | Twitter
Profile Image for Jess Owens.
350 reviews5,039 followers
November 9, 2022
Whimsical, cozy, precious, heartwarming, endearing, joyful read. I needed that .
Profile Image for Whiskers & Ink ( allie ☁️ ).
110 reviews14 followers
September 28, 2023
“It’s not always enough to go looking for the place we belong. Sometimes we need to make that place.”

Alright, elephants out first: I did not like this book. On paper the description was hitting all the right beats: found family, sunshine meets grumpy, and a sweet, sweet dollop of magic to coat it all. I was incredibly excited for what was to come after the first chapter. Yet the more I read, the higher my frustration mounted. But I figured it was just an issue with my reading mood, so I paused halfway through and finished something else instead, then came back...

Turns out it wasn’t my mood—I just don’t vibe with this book 🤡 Maybe it’s the pages and pages of constant magic exposition, or the forced conflict, or the grim plot twist at the end, or the fact that I disliked every single character except the children, or everything combined, but the point is The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches got professionally on my nerves.

To be clear and fair: I don’t think this book is bad. This is perhaps the better of the recent books to come out of the witchy romance boom. Though I won’t go as far as calling it a ‘magic system,’ it’s got a relatively fleshed-out (albeit very info-dumpy) understanding of the magic, and it doesn’t fall into the pit of making it a cure-all fix-all panacea. It has a smooth prose and a beautifully encouraging message on found family. I think people who love candy-coated quirky stories will find this incredibly comforting. The bones I’m about to pick are mine alone.

So what’s my problem? Many, apparently. Among my lighter quibbles, I’ll say I was generally bored with the story, I didn’t find the prose half as magical as I hoped it would be, and also thought the whole thing was aggressively twee (and listen, I like twee!!!). I felt like there was zero chemistry between the leads. There was no substance to their attraction beyond “you’re hot.” It has a ton of awkward magic info drops that felt like the equivalent of an actor in a film turning to the camera and explaining something everyone else in the scene knows, but is clearly getting stated for the audience. It was very cringy.

“I’ve been thinking about what might happen if I combined star shavings, lavender, pollen, and moonlight,” Mika said to her. Circe blew out a sleepy breath. Mika nodded. “I know, I know. You think it’s a bad idea to put stars and moonlight in the same potion. You think they’ll be too powerful together, or that they’ll react unpredictably because neither comes from the earth.” She clicked her tongue thoughtfully, catching a luminous shard drifting past her. “But what if I combined them and something spectacular happened?”

(For the record, Circe is her dog.)

But the biggest issue I had is that I couldn’t stand Jamie. And as any romance reader knows, if you don’t like the lead hero of a romance, your enjoyment is screwed.

I couldn’t get past his petulant manchild attitude.
Throughout a good chunk of the book Jamie is both enraged by the fact that Mika has never felt any sense of belonging to a place ever, yet simultaneously constantly questions her capabilities, distrusts her, and pushes against her doing anything with the children. Even more frustrating is Mika’s hyper kind and goofy attitude about it. She waves off his nasty remarks without offence, because after all, he’s just worried for the children!

Let me tell you something: There is nothing that boils my piss faster than people excusing men’s shitty attitudes and poor social skills because “they mean well.” (Yes, this is a work of fiction, but let me be mad, damn it.) I could have taken it if Mika had more bite to her, had at least been taken aback and felt insulted by this treatment, but she’s sunshine and smiles all around, and I’m tired of sunshine-grumpy dynamics where the woman is the one doing all the heavy lifting.

Worse, the grim plot twist at the end ruined the little enjoyment I did have in the second half, because it essentially wrecks the entire setup. If you’re just reading this review for funsies and don’t mind being spoiled, here it goes:

TL;DR: I got so frustrated with this book I had to finish the last 10% on text-to-speech. Did I dislike it for the plot twist, or did the plot twist confirm my dislike? Chicken or the egg 🐔 Who knows, but a whole lot of people seem to like it, and I’ll stress, once again, that I don’t think it’s a bad book. The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches is far more diverse than most other witchy romances out there, and though it’s only a passing comment that doesn’t get explored in depth, it’s worth mentioning that it acknowledges the problematic aspects of removing a young child from their culture and raising them unconnected to it. I think there’s a lot in here to like... It just wasn’t for me 🤷‍♀️


TW: discussions of parental neglect & abuse
Profile Image for Gillian.
188 reviews274 followers
April 2, 2023
4.5 stars!

“The thing is, being a witch is extraordinary. It might seem sometimes that all we are is odd and different, but the truth is, we’re amazing. We’re part of the earth below us and the sky above us.”

I really liked this book! This was such a fun and heartwarming love story about belonging, learning that you do deserve love, finding your home and family. This book follows Mika, a witch and an orphan, who has been alone for most of her life and knows that she has to hide her magic. Then Mika receives a message on her online account asking her to teach three young witches to control their magic. Mika decides to go to Nowhere House to help the witches and meets the other residents of the house, a gardener, a retired actor and a caretaker, and Jamie, a grumpy librarian. Eventually Mika must decide whether the family she found is worth risking her magic for.

"It's not always enough to go looking for the place we belong. Sometimes we need to make that place."

I was swept up in this enchanting story from the very beginning. The witty and descriptive writing helped me picture the events in my head vividly. I loved the witchy and festive vibes in this book. The plot was interesting and exciting and there were several plot twists that I didn't expect. The characters are each so complex and relatable. I loved Mika, she is resilient, strong, kind, independent, and caring. I loved her character development, she learned a lot about herself and realized that she does deserve to be loved and can be herself around the people who care for her. I love Jamie so much, he is kind, charming, caring, handsome, and protective. I really enjoyed seeing him grow and realize that he can move past his difficult childhood and that there is someone who cares for him. I really liked the side characters, especially Rosetta, Altamira, Ken and Ian. I loved Mika and Jamie's relationship, they are perfect for each other and are able to see that they complement each other. The slow-burn romance and chemistry between the characters was so good! I can relate to Mika and Jamie in a few ways, similar to Mika and Jamie, I love to read and like Jamie I am shy during social interactions. I really appreciated how the author discussed anxiety and the difficult situations that the characters dealt with. The ending was so good and I'm so happy that Mika and Jamie got a happy ending!

I recommend this book to anyone who loves romance, witch books, slow-burn romance, grumpy and sunshine love, and great characters.
Profile Image for Kat (will try to catch up soon!).
269 reviews875 followers
April 19, 2023
This book has cast its spell … consider me charmed!

Part romance, part fantasy, part “found family” fiction, this story gave me all the House in the Cerulean Sea vibes while being very much its own magical story. Sangu Mandanna will be a new-to-me author to watch!

Synopsis: Thirty-one year old Mika Moon was brought up to believe that the power of too many witches existing in close proximity is dangerous. Due to this, she’s led a largely lonely and solitary life where she can’t truly be herself. One outlet for her, though, is her YouTube channel where she performs magic, knowing that no one actually believes it’s real. Well … almost no one.

Convinced that she’s actually a witch, aged retired actor Ian invites Mika to Nowhere House, where he lives with his husband, Ken, housekeeper Lucie, librarian Jamie, and three precocious young witches named Rosette, Terracotta and Altamira, wards of Lillian Nowhere, herself a witch and the owner of the house. While Lillian is away, he hopes that Mika can teach these young witches how to control their power before a visit from a solicitor in six weeks’ time that will determine whether they can stay at Nowhere House.

Needless to say, things don’t quite go to plan when this eclectic bunch get together! The girls’ unintentional magic hijinks were particularly funny.

My thoughts: Mika is a strong, funny, intelligent female MC, which is SO refreshing. She’s kind and level-headed, and despite her past trauma, isn’t portrayed as a victim. Her story arc of finding her ‘family’ at Nowhere House was so touching and sweet. I also enjoyed seeing her sunshiney personality melt big ol’ grump Jamie’s heart. They had fun chemistry (and a bit of steam)!

Ian is flamboyant and hilarious and creates as many problems as he tries to solve! It was funny to watch Ken, Lucie and Jamie try to keep him in check. The girls fight as children do, but at the heart of it, they fiercely love one another and it was sweet to see them find a place in their hearts for Mika too.

This story is a virtual melting pot of diversity which is also refreshing. It has White, Black, British, Indian, Irish, Vietnamese, Palestinian, and Japanese characters, two same-sex couples, the spectrum of ages, yet it never feels like it’s TRYING to hit you over the head with its diversity. Oh, and Mika has an adorable dog named, Circe, too. So cute!

The story is written in third person, following Mika’s POV primarily. It’s funny and heartwarming, while tackling a few serious issues like loneliness, manipulation and trauma without ever becoming heavy. I listened on audio narrated by Samara MacLaren, who did an absolutely brilliant job with all the voicing of genders, ages and accents. She has such a soothing voice. If you want a little bit of magic and a whole lot of heart, this is a wonderful story for any time of year!

★★★★ ½
Profile Image for benedicta.
348 reviews480 followers
August 8, 2023
2.5⭐️ cute but pass 💅🏾 to paraphrase urwa's review "it felt like eating icing with no cake at all", just too twee
Displaying 1 - 30 of 26,525 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.